Key Takeaways
- Section 52 makes the Constitution supreme: an inconsistent law is of no force or effect
- A law that limits a Charter right survives only if the government justifies it under the Oakes test
- The notwithstanding clause shields laws from some rights for 5 years — never voting or language rights
Who has the final word in Canada — Parliament, or the Constitution?
The Constitution does. Section 52(1) of the Constitution Act, 1982 states it in one sentence: "The Constitution of Canada is the supreme law of Canada, and any law that is inconsistent with the provisions of the Constitution is, to the extent of the inconsistency, of no force or effect."
Courts do not repeal laws. When a law collides with the Constitution, judges declare it inoperative — but only to the extent of the collision, and only after a process with several distinct gates.
Gate one: someone has to sue — and warn the governments
Courts cannot go hunting for unconstitutional laws. A person directly affected can challenge a law — an accused person, for example, can attack the very law they are charged under; that is how the famous Oakes case began. Others can sometimes obtain public-interest standing if the issue is serious, they have a genuine stake, and the suit is a reasonable way to get the question before a court.
Then comes a step most people never hear about: in some proceedings, the attorneys general must be notified so governments can show up and defend their law. In the Federal Court, for example, section 57 of the Federal Courts Act requires at least 10 days' notice before a constitutional question is argued. No court quietly strikes down a statute in an empty room.
Gate two: the Oakes test — the government must justify the limit
First, the challenger proves the law limits a Charter right. Then the burden flips: under section 1, the government must show the limit is "demonstrably justified in a free and democratic society" — with real evidence, on a balance of probabilities. The Supreme Court's 1986 decision in R. v. Oakes built the test still used today:
- A pressing and substantial objective — the law's goal must be important enough to justify limiting a right at all.
- Rational connection — the measure must actually serve that goal, not be arbitrary.
- Minimal impairment — the right must be limited no more than reasonably necessary.
- Proportionality of effects — the law's benefits must outweigh its harm to the right.
Oakes itself shows the test has teeth. A law presumed that anyone caught possessing a narcotic intended to traffic — unless they proved otherwise. The provision violated the presumption of innocence and failed at rational connection: possessing a small amount simply does not logically prove intent to sell. The provision fell.
The remedy toolbox: surgery, not demolition
Because section 52 invalidates a law only "to the extent of the inconsistency," courts reach for the least intrusive fix: striking the offending provision, severing the bad words, reading down ambiguous wording to a constitutional meaning, or reading in a group the law wrongly excluded.
The most dramatic tool is the suspended declaration of invalidity: the court declares the law invalid but delays the effect so the legislature can write a replacement. In Carter v. Canada (2015), the Supreme Court struck down the Criminal Code bans on physician-assisted dying as violating section 7 — then suspended the declaration for 12 months so Parliament could legislate rather than face a legal vacuum.
The escape hatch: section 33, the notwithstanding clause
A legislature can declare that a law operates "notwithstanding" certain Charter provisions. The mechanics are strict:
- It covers only section 2 (fundamental freedoms) and sections 7–15 (legal and equality rights).
- The declaration must be express and written into a statute.
- It expires after five years — renewable, five years at a time.
- It can be used pre-emptively, before any court rules, and courts police only whether the formal requirements were met.
- The federal Parliament has never used it.
But section 33 has limits. It cannot shield a law from every constitutional challenge — only from challenges based on the specified Charter rights. Other constitutional problems, such as a division-of-powers issue, remain open. And some rights are beyond its reach entirely: democratic rights (vote, elections, annual sittings), mobility rights, and language rights can never be shielded.
Real life has tested it. Quebec's Bill 21 (2019), the religious-symbols law, invoked section 33 in advance — and renewed the declaration in 2024. Ontario's 2018 threat to use it over the Toronto council ruling was never enacted. Ontario did enact it in the 2022 Keeping Students in Class Act, which imposed a contract on education workers with fines up to $4,000 a day for individuals — then repealed the law 11 days later, deemed never to have been in force, after a province-wide walkout.
The Twikup Take
The system is a balance of three forces: courts can void laws, but only through standing, notice, justification and surgical remedies; governments can defend limits, but must prove them under Oakes; and legislatures hold one override — narrow, temporary, and politically expensive. Every actor can check the others. Nobody gets the last word forever.
Image: Illustrative image.
