Key Takeaways
- Fixed means your rate and payment stay put.
- Variable follows the prime rate.
- Breaking a fixed mortgage can cost far more.
The two rates, in FCAC's words
A fixed rate "stays the same for the entire term," the Financial Consumer Agency of Canada says — and your payments stay the same too. It's usually higher than a variable rate for a similar term, because you're paying for certainty.
A variable rate "may increase and decrease during the term" and is typically lower to start. But variable comes in two flavours that borrowers constantly confuse:
- Fixed payment, variable rate: your payment never changes, but the split between principal and interest shifts. If rates rise far enough to hit your contract's trigger point, the lender may raise your payment.
- Adjustable payment: the payment itself moves with the rate, while a set amount always goes to principal.
Your term — how long the contract runs — can range from a few months to five years or longer. At each term's end, you renew and renegotiate the rate.
How a variable rate actually moves
A variable rate is your lender's prime rate, plus or minus an adjustment (for example, prime − 0.50%). It changes automatically when prime changes. And prime, per the Bank of Canada, is set by each institution "as a function of its cost of funding, which, in turn, is influenced by the target for the overnight rate set by the Bank of Canada." Translation: the Bank moves its policy rate, prime follows, and your variable rate follows prime — usually within days.
The cost of leaving early
This is where fixed and variable really diverge. FCAC: a prepayment penalty "will usually be the higher of three months' interest on what you still owe, or the interest rate differential (IRD)." Lenders generally use the IRD when your contract rate is above today's rates and you signed within the last five years — and it can dwarf the three-month figure. FCAC's own example: a $200,000 balance at 6% with 36 months left, against a current 3-year rate of 4%, produces a $3,000 three-month penalty but a $12,000 IRD.
Your prepayment privilege — extra payments you can make penalty-free, like a "10+10" allowing 10% payment increases and a 10% lump sum yearly — is set in your contract, varies by lender, and unused amounts usually can't be carried forward.
The stress test sits above both
Whichever you choose, a federally regulated lender must qualify you at the higher of 5.25% or your contract rate plus 2% — proof you could still afford the mortgage if rates rose. Lenders also watch your housing-cost ratio (≤39% of gross income) and total debt ratio (≤44%).
The Twikup Take
Fixed buys sleep; variable buys a lower starting rate and a live connection to the Bank of Canada. The question nobody asks at signing — "what does it cost me to leave?" — is the one that matters most if life changes mid-term. Read the penalty clause before you fall in love with either rate.
Image: Illustrative image.
