Key Takeaways
- Two retirees with $500,000, $25,000 annual withdrawals and identical returns (−20%, +10%, +10%) end $15,750 apart after three years purely because of the order the returns arrived
- Without withdrawals, order is irrelevant — both sequences end at $484,000; sequence risk is created by forced selling during downturns, and peaks in the decade around retirement.
- Defences include holding one to two years of spending in cash or short-term bonds, flexible withdrawals, guaranteed income floors like CPP and OAS, and a somewhat more conservative
Same money. Same markets. A $15,750 difference.
Two retirees start with $500,000 each. Both withdraw $25,000 at the beginning of every year. Both experience the exact same three market returns: one year down 20%, two years up 10%.
You might expect them to finish with the same amount. They don't. And the reason could change how you plan your retirement.
The retiree who crashes first
Retiree A gets the worst year immediately. After withdrawing $25,000, the remaining $475,000 falls 20%, leaving $380,000. Year two: another $25,000 withdrawal, followed by a 10% gain. Balance: $390,500. Year three: another withdrawal and another 10% gain. Final balance: $402,050.
Now reverse the order.
The retiree who crashes last
Retiree B experiences the two good years first. Year one: withdraw $25,000, then gain 10%. Balance: $522,500. Year two: withdraw another $25,000, then gain 10%. Balance: $547,250. Year three: withdraw $25,000, then suffer the 20% crash. Final balance: $417,800.
Same starting money. Same withdrawals. Same market returns. But Retiree B finishes with $15,750 more. The only difference? Timing.
And over a 25- or 30-year retirement, that difference can become far more serious. An early crash can permanently shorten a portfolio's life, while the same crash arriving later may be easier to survive.
Why taking money out changes everything
Here's the surprising part. Remove the withdrawals, and both retirees finish with exactly $484,000. Why? Because multiplication doesn't care about order.
But retirement changes the equation. When markets fall and you still need money for groceries, housing and bills, you may have to sell investments at depressed prices. Those investments can no longer participate in the recovery. Worse, each withdrawal from a smaller portfolio consumes a larger percentage of what remains. That's sequence-of-returns risk.
While you're accumulating investments, regular contributions can let you buy more shares at lower prices. Once you're withdrawing, the same downturn can work against you. The danger is especially important during roughly the decade surrounding retirement, when portfolios are often largest and withdrawals are beginning.
Four ways to protect your retirement
You cannot control when markets crash. But you can reduce how much a crash forces you to sell.
1. Keep a cash cushion. Holding one to two years of spending in cash or short-term bonds can help cover withdrawals during market declines, giving equities time to recover, although recovery is never guaranteed.
2. Make withdrawals flexible. Reducing spending after a bad market year means selling fewer investments when prices are low.
3. Build guaranteed income. CPP, OAS, pensions and annuities can reduce how much money you need to withdraw from investments.
4. Consider a more conservative portfolio near retirement. Giving up some potential long-term growth may reduce the damage from a severe early downturn.
None of these strategies eliminates risk. And none requires predicting the next crash. Because nobody knows whether the worst market year will arrive at the beginning, middle or end of retirement.
The Twikup Take
Two people can earn the same market returns and still experience very different retirements. That's the danger of relying on averages. Your portfolio doesn't live through an average. It lives through real market years, while you withdraw real money to pay real bills. A bad year at the wrong time can do more damage than the same bad year later. Don't just plan for how much the market might return. Plan for what happens if the market falls when you need your money most.
Image: Illustrative image.
