Key Takeaways

  • Bill C-10 received Royal Assent on November 19, creating a Commissioner for Modern Treaty Implementation as an independent Agent of Parliament
  • The Commissioner will audit federal implementation of Modern Treaty commitments and report directly to Parliament
  • No first Commissioner or funding figure has been announced yet

A watchdog 20 years in the asking

Canada finally gets an independent watchdog for its treaty promises.

For more than 20 years, Modern Treaty partners have asked Ottawa for one thing: independent oversight of its treaty promises.

As of November 19, they finally have it — in law.

Bill C-10 received Royal Assent, establishing the Commissioner for Modern Treaty Implementation — a new independent Agent of Parliament.

The Commissioner will conduct reviews and performance audits of how the federal government implements its Modern Treaty commitments, and report findings directly to Parliament. The office's scope is Modern Treaties alone: it identifies where implementation is falling short and recommends fixes, operating independently of the government it examines.

Modern Treaties have underpinned reconciliation for more than 50 years, settling land ownership and Indigenous rights and supporting self-government. The new office also answers commitments in Canada's Collaborative Modern Treaty Implementation Policy and the UN Declaration Act Action Plan.

"A Commissioner for Modern Treaty Implementation will help Canada be a better Treaty partner," said Crown-Indigenous Relations Minister Rebecca Alty. "For more than 20 years, Indigenous leaders and Modern Treaty partners have called for stronger oversight and accountability."

"Our treaties are constitutionally protected, and the commitments made under them must be honoured," said Gloria Uluqsi, President of Nunavut Tunngavik Incorporated. "The Commissioner will help hold Canada accountable."

What we still don't know

The release names no first Commissioner and sets out no funding figure — those announcements are still to come.

The Twikup Take

Treaties fail quietly — not in courtrooms, but in a hundred unimplemented clauses. An auditor who reports to Parliament rather than to the department being audited is the structural fix Treaty partners asked for. The appointment and the budget will show whether Ottawa means it.

Image: Centre Block, Ottawa, Southeast view, by DXR, CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons.

Sources