Key Takeaways

  • Dumping means selling into Canada below the home-market price; Canada's answer is a duty equal to the gap, under the Special Import Measures Act.
  • Two agencies split the case: the CBSA measures the dumping or subsidy, and the independent CITT decides whether it injures Canadian industry.
  • No injury finding, no duties — however much dumping exists. A full case takes about seven months, and duties then run at least five years.

Selling cheap is legal. Selling below your home price to kill a Canadian competitor is not

Every country says it wants competition. Canada's trade-remedy law draws the line at a specific kind of cheap: dumping — selling goods to Canadian importers for less than comparable goods sell for at home, or at prices that do not cover costs — and subsidizing, where a foreign government helps its exporters undercut the market. The system that polices both is the Special Import Measures Act, SIMA, and it runs on a two-key design: one agency measures the unfairness, a completely separate one decides whether it actually hurt anyone.

The arithmetic at the heart of every case

The Canada Border Services Agency investigates. Its core calculation fits in one line: normal value minus export price equals the anti-dumping duty. Normal value is generally what the good sells for in its home market; where that cannot be used, it is built up from production costs plus reasonable amounts for overhead and profit. Export price is the exporter's selling price to Canada, minus export charges such as freight and insurance. The CBSA's own guide works an example: an invoice of $2.30 less $0.10 freight gives an export price of $2.20; against a normal value of $2.50, the duty owing is $0.30 per unit. If the export price matches or beats the normal value, no duty is payable at all.

Subsidies get the parallel treatment: the countervailing duty equals the amount of subsidy per unit. And the system has a floor for trivial cases — a dumping margin under 2 per cent of the export price, or a subsidy under 1 per cent, is normally treated as insignificant. Exporters who refuse to cooperate get a ministerial specification instead — a set percentage that, the CBSA notes, generally results in a higher assessment.

The second key: injury, decided independently

Dumping alone is not enough. The Canadian International Trade Tribunal — independent of the CBSA — must find that the dumped or subsidized imports are causing injury to Canadian industry: reduced prices, lost sales, lost market share, falling profits, jobs affected. As the CBSA puts it, "a positive injury decision by the CITT provides the authority for the CBSA to impose anti-dumping or countervailing duty." No injury finding, no duties, however lopsided the pricing was.

Cases usually start with a complaint from Canadian producers — the CBSA requires producers representing at least 25 per cent of domestic production to support it, with support outweighing opposition. From there the clockwork runs about seven months: the CBSA confirms the complaint is properly documented within 21 days, decides whether to initiate within about 30, and the CITT makes a preliminary injury call within 60 days — a negative answer ends everything on the spot. The CBSA's preliminary determination lands around day 90, and provisional duties can be collected from that point so producers are protected while the case finishes. Final determinations follow, and if both agencies land on yes, duties are imposed for at least five years, with a review before they expire.

What it looks like in practice, right now

These are not theoretical instruments. On September 2, 2026, the CBSA made preliminary determinations that steel racks from China were being both dumped and subsidized, and provisional duties became payable that day: one named exporter was assessed 0.0 per cent dumping plus 7.0 per cent subsidy, while all other exporters face 6.1 per cent plus 7.0 per cent — 13.1 per cent combined. A measure already in force on steel strapping shows the top end of the scale: after final determinations in December 2025 and a CITT injury finding on January 14, 2026, exporters without their own specific rate pay anti-dumping duty of 47.9 per cent of the export price on goods from China and Türkiye, plus a countervailing duty of 0.44 Chinese yuan per kilogram on the Chinese goods.

There is also an off-ramp: an exporter or foreign government can offer an undertaking — a commitment to change its pricing or subsidizing so the harm disappears — which generally suspends both tracks with no duties collected.

The Twikup Take

SIMA is Canada's pressure valve between open trade and fair trade. Its discipline is the split decision: the border agency can prove dumping all day, but an independent tribunal still has to be persuaded that Canadian industry was actually injured before a single dollar of duty sticks. That is why the system's outcomes range from a 7 per cent provisional duty on steel racks to nearly 48 per cent on steel strapping — the duty is not a political number. It is, by law, the measured size of the gap.

Image: Illustrative image.

Sources